Death Note's premise and the ethics of a power to kill by writing

Such interesting dilemmas arise when you think too deeply on some topics.

What would “L” have done had he been given the Death Note “book”, would he be like Light is, & would they switch places in the story now instead.

They are so much alike in many ways “even friends”, Ryukazi “L” assures himself he would never go so far as Kira “Light”… but did L have one?

What would happen had he gotten it instead & the power to do as you wish to dissolve bullies & evil peoples from the world of life… or any human no less.

How far would one go to not let it fall into someone else hands.

Where is the line you draw, were you given power of that like… of a lower case “god”.

Would you bite the apple… anyone?

Temptations can be all consuming while in hand.

:face_with_monocle: ~QS

1 Like

hmmm…

yeah…

*casually whistles…

i am certain if the death note were real… it wouldn’t be used as it would be… Like if it fell into a certain group’s hands… this wouldn’t be good… (yes the group you the reader are thinking.)

There are likely not many people in the world who would use it like Light would. However; those few would likely be unlikely to use it due to empathy. You would have to have some level of sociopathy in order to utilize the book. Or select the really bad people… which then would look awfully suspicious.

(my vagueness is key here.)

Think about it… what would happen if a large group of politicians would suddenly have mysterious deaths… it would not be fun… or in the other hand… a bunch of scientists… whom could be working on how to build time travel…

or worse… having someone go haywire and grabbing a phonebook and just writing names alphabetically… only for the sheer joy of it…

then there would be the skeptic whom would test this a few dozen times to finally conclude that they are not on drugs and the death god is not a hallucination of some lcd trip that they had accidentally taken a drink of at a party the previous weekend… then sets it aside after resolving this… only to continue being skeptical coming up with ways that it could have been debunked… what a plotline that would be.

:smiley: i personally wouldn’t use it… because it would completely confuse any investigator that would try to profile this… UwU it would just instinctively confuse them.

1 Like

If it was real, the temptation is real also. No?

All the innocent people one could save, if only one could carry… the moral responsibility justly.

1 Like

what if these kinds of things are real.

what if pushing the button, instead killed anyone you wish.

What if you received nothing for doing it & the person never came to remove it after pushed? :face_with_raised_eyebrow:~QS

1 Like

Now consider this. in the Scenario for Ai Takeover I posted a video.

In this video it talks about school shooting & creating clones of those lost children.

Would you use Death Note/The Button to stop something like this?

Who would be worse for the killing?
You for letting the kid who shoots up the school or yourself for stopping it?
You are both killers at this point in a sense aren’t you “eventually”?

A real post that was removed recently about a kid who claimed they wanted to shoot up thier school this coming year?

it has been removed but I can give you evidence the post was very real, the kid claims they want to be like the Doom school shooters kids, even in a sense looking up to them, they wanted to do it… this year when the school year begins, they have everything they needed. They were uncertain if they would die by cop or do themselves in like the two did.

what if you were powerless to stop it any other way but this one gift?

:sob:~QS

Note: At least 15 dead “certain” targets on this spree, they wanted the most… the rest are just causalities for their sense of life’s injustices

Think of it this way; (which is another way of explaining on how not to change things on time travel.)

These tragic events are likely an inspiration for at least one person. Columbine school shooting inspired me to look deeper into how a young teen would come up with these ideas; aside from this; it also inspired me to not do the same as they did. In otherwords; we wouldn’t be here talking if it never happened. (I would be dead or in prison.)

Building on this structure; the people in power should have done something more effectively than just twiddling their thumbs. The people in power are the politicians.

Now look at how the politicians responded to each and every mass shooting since. Which are either gonna be “Thoughts and Prayers” or “We are gonna do everything in our power to do something to stop this”

We didn’t have this many shootings prior to Columbine… wait… no that isn’t true… the shootings were popularized through media coverage. In the mind of a shooter; it would be for the glorification. This justification of glorification comes from a lack of validation of a child’s existence. The parents are more often than not abusive and neglectful of their child… thusly they seek the validation in a means of where they get it… and that comes from various entertainment outlets.

The sole people who are responsible are the parents; and recently we have seen this take shape. However… let’s look at the numbers since we held parents responsible…

A total of 273 people have been killed and 1,202 people have been wounded in 282 shootings, as of July 31, 2026. - List of mass shootings in the United States in 2026 - Wikipedia

A total of 420 people were killed and 1,900 people wounded in 425 shootings. - List of mass shootings in the United States in 2025 - Wikipedia

A total of 712 people were killed and 2,389 people were wounded in 587 shootings. - List of mass shootings in the United States in 2024 - Wikipedia

There were 614 mass shootings in 2020 that fit the inclusion criteria of this article, resulting in 446 deaths and 2,515 injuries, for a total of 2,961 victims. - List of mass shootings in the United States in 2020 - Wikipedia

Essentially that would be filling the death note quite a bit. (i skipped the years of 2021-2023.) Remember what happened in 2020… quarantine. 614 shootings…

Now not all of these shootings included a death… and a few of them include many deaths.

Imagine if the news covered this tragedy in terms of glorifying the shooter over the loss of life…

This happened nearly 100 years ago.

then compare that with this… (notice how the kill count is glorified here.)

Just so you know; Columbine was initially gonna be a bomb explosion but that failed so they took plan b. Imagine how many more deaths would have ensued…

One thing about this is; the public has no idea the name of the mass shooter; until after the fact and after there is an investigation; and often times; they are likely very discreet about this due to the imcompetence of the real people in power to make a change for the last three decades.

Think bigger… who would be more likely a target for these things…

One group would go with someone like Mamdani, while the other would go for Trump. For issuing the name. It boils down to the holder of the Death Note’s morality of justice. While in this same light… a real instance happened… just in a more realistic sense.

Look at how things have shaped since then…

But the relations have been long standing.

All in all; it wouldn’t be our responsibility to write in a name of a person… (and giving up half our life just to see the name wouldn’t be wise either; unless we are already knocking on death’s door. Which then i would have a hayday writing names.

Now; the responses of the death of Charlie Kirk gives another means of feedback. No matter the political standings of a person; there are people who look up to the one’s who are dead. There are people who would equally be thankful for the person’s death.

If i had the power i wouldn’t write names of all the school shooters; i would write a lot fewer names and consider the consequences of what would entail.

You can remove a politician from office; though the ones who are really bad people who deserve their name be put in the book; would have a dozen more; and their followers would likely respond with a violent retaliation. Which would be way thousands of names at the end of it all.

This is how revolutions start as well… (when a dictator uses various means to amp up their followers and ostrasize the naysayers.) So; it really is an equal temperance of inspiration on both sides of the same coin.

In leau of my being a murderer after this; i would be reluctant to write even one name… Though i would love to write about 23 names. (you know me well enough to know which names i would write.)

Then again; some of those names include old people who could die at any minute… so it would just tarnish my soul to end someone who would pass away in a few months… due to being old.

I wouldn’t let my emotions get the better of me in otherwords.

1 Like

The man for a position of power is the man who does not want the power.

2 Likes

I believe that family absolutely has something to do with this kind of issue.

The simple fact that alienation casues many issue with someone who is not strong enough yet in there own formation, you never know which path they will choose.
Light or darkness. It is a scary thing. But not all children form the same way. You could raise many children in the same ways, same blessings & still have different children. this is a hard one. But structure does matter, you need both discipline & love. Not cruel discipline, nor over abundant love. Again this is a hard one becasue you have children going up with neither & technology which also isolates. Context with/of how we learn matters.

Adults are there own issue, already formed people are much harder to yet change.

this is a problem all of it is own that is for sure.

I called it a gift becasue somethings are handed to you, but somethings are not a gift… at all are they?

it is how you use such things that determine whether it is a true gift, or… a curse against you.

Ahhh, The Trolley Problem.

No comment.

Truly you rose above, this was never just about schools, this was only a place for one foot to take hold. So much… more power now one realizes they would hold. You haven’t written one note… & you thinking bigger you are!

I can take a knee to this statement alone! Only true wisdom knows. ~QS

1 Like

What if pushing the button grants you a million dollars but by entering the game, your name is put on the list of candidates to be killed next time.

2 Likes